This summer has been a whirlwind. Starting in mid-June, I kicked things off by speaking at the TBEX travel content creator conference in Quebec City—a truly inspiring experience that I highly recommend if you’re in that space. From there, I went on a much-needed vacation to Grand Cayman with my husband, followed by a memorable trip to Ireland with my mom and sister. While it may have looked a little crazy from the outside (and honestly, it was), I’ve still been keeping an eye on what’s been happening in the Pinterest world. A few things stood out that I wanted to share before diving into today’s big question: do Pinterest followers matter?
The Pinterest Traffic Glitch and Account Warnings
While I was traveling, there were a couple of bumps in the Pinterest landscape. First, there was a weird shift in how Google Analytics 4 reported Pinterest traffic—some of it moved to “direct,” making it seem like Pinterest traffic had plummeted overnight. Thankfully, the traffic didn’t disappear; it was just being categorized differently. Still, this glitch matters if you rely on Pinterest for monetized traffic, and we’re monitoring it closely. Additionally, Pinterest issued a wave of copyright complaint notifications. If you received one, check whether it’s your pin or just something saved to your account—often, it’s nothing to worry about. And for those wondering about the “Visit Site” button on pins, we’ve got a detailed post on our blog about that too.
Do Followers on Pinterest Actually Matter?
So let’s get into it: do Pinterest followers actually make a difference? This question comes up a lot, especially from people used to platforms like Instagram or TikTok, where follower count = reach. Pinterest has never quite worked that way. It’s always prioritized content over follower numbers, and I wanted to test whether that’s still true today. I dug into four different client accounts to see how follower counts matched up with actual traffic, and the results were eye-opening. In multiple cases, accounts with fewer followers generated significantly more traffic—sometimes double or even ten times as much.
Want to read this later?
We'll email this post to you, so you can come back to it later! Let us know what you thought!
Four Real-World Examples That Break the Follower Myth
Let me give you the highlights. One account with 108,000 followers saw a massive 82% traffic increase over three months with only a 1.3% follower growth. Another account with 218,000 followers (more than double the first) had less than half the traffic. A third example had under 100,000 followers and produced over 300,000 sessions in a month—ten times the traffic of higher-follower accounts—simply because their content aligned better with Pinterest’s discovery engine. Finally, one of my favorite examples: a small account with just 4,000 followers outperformed a 218,000-follower account, proving that smart content beats follower count any day.
Focus on What Actually Drives Results
If you’re just starting out on Pinterest, or even coming back after a break, I hope these examples encourage you. It can be frustrating to see slow growth, especially when you’re used to platforms that reward rapid follower increases. But Pinterest is different. It’s a search and discovery platform—content is king. Your energy is better spent on creating quality pins that meet user needs than obsessing over follower numbers. Stick with it for 6 to 9 months, and you’ll start to see real traction. I’d love to hear your thoughts—drop me a note at [email protected] or comment below. Let’s keep demystifying Pinterest, together.
Related Pinterest Marketing Resources:
Shop: Simple Pin Media Pinterest Blueprint Mini Course
Watch: What it’s like to have 4 million followers on Pinterest
